LONG BACKSTORY FOR CONTEXT:
I am certain that I’m not the only person who sets Arbitrary Rules to Live By and then panics if any one of those rules is ever violated. I have policies regarding when to use my debit card vs. my credit card, lists of foods that are appropriate to serve to dinner guests (and longer lists re: what not to serve, EVER!), and a detailed mental flow chart of acceptable conversation topics to use with family members, friends, and perfect strangers.
These rules have not been written in stone by any means (hence the title: arbitrary), but I can’t help feeling a flutter in my tummy every time I whip out my Visa instead of my bank card or commit the unthinkable act and serve my guests hummus. (I love garlic, but will they?) I won’t even mention the awkward conversation I once had with a professor about Blackberries. He was talking about the latest technological gadget… but I was fixated on those delicious, juicy fruits. I should have remembered to never engage in tech talk with my intellectual superiors.

Pretending we were on our honeymoon in Alaska (2004), much to the delight and cooing of the other passengers on board the Lu-Lu Belle. We had been dating for all of 7 months but felt very much like we were in a honeymoon phase.
Anyway. One of my most steadfast rules growing up was the 8 Year Rule. I decreed to myself that I would never date anybody more than 8 years older than me, specifically because that would make my beau closer to my mom’s age than to mine. I felt that it would be very awkward and possibly gross/wrong to date somebody in my mom and dad’s league, so I stuck to this rule like gum sticks to shoes. (If you are confused by the math, remember that I am the product of teen parents– my mom was 16 years old when she gave birth to me.)
Funnily enough, Marty also had an Arbitrary, Age-Related Rule for potential partners. His rule wasn’t based on the immutable age difference between himself and his parents, though– nope. Instead, after ending a long-term relationship with a woman who was 29 years old according to the calendar (but maybe 18 years old on the maturity scale), he decided that he would Never Again Date Anybody Younger Than 29.
Well.
The night that Marty and I met each other, we started falling in deep, crazy love before we even knew the most basic information about each other. Like whether Marty was old enough to be my dad. We were marveling at just how amazing the other person was– “He’s a vegetarian, too? Is this heaven??“; “She usually does something new-agey to mark every Solstice and Equinox? Is she an angel??“– and then I totally ruined the moment by asking Marty his age.
[insert 80s-style screeching of a needle on a spinning record]
He whispered that he was 32. What?! 8 Year Rule: Violated by 2 whole years! (2 and a half years when you factored in his winter birthday and my summer one.)
I felt like I had been punched in the gut and again in the head. Could I possibly date somebody who was an entire decade older than me, even if he was a Complete and Total Marvel, the very embodiment of Heaven on Earth?
Taking advantage of the sour-feeling that was now lingering slightly in the air, Marty decided to ask me my age. For those of you who are not math-inclined and didn’t already figure it out, I was 22. Say what?! ‘Must Be 29+ Years Old To Ride’ Rule: Violated by a whopping 7 years!
I think we both panicked a little (breaking rules is bad and carries scary consequences!), but fortunately, our blossoming love flower was already planted too deeply for our flagrant age violations to matter very much. We resumed our sickening admiration of each other and have continued to fawn over each other to this day. (Marty’s mom groans to her friends that we stare at each other like we are exquisite, fine art masterpieces, and my mom usually asks me, “Do you still pet Marty like a puppy?” when we talk on the phone. The answer is always ‘yes’. Of course I still do.)
Aaaannnyway…. Our 10-year age difference might have been more shocking when I was a fresh 22 and Marty was a more seasoned 32. However, time has passed and it doesn’t seem so crazy to be dating a 40-something man in my 30s. Marty turns 41 today, and I’m so glad I was a badass rule disobeyer back in the day and gave our relationship a chance! After all, Arbitrary Rules were made to be broken, right? (Even if it does mean my husband and both my parents are all in their 40s for now. Ahem.)
Join me in wishing Marty a Happy 41st, dear readers!



Dana, this made me giggle a bit.
I’m glad you both allowed the “age rules” to be set aside for the greater good … ’cause it’s pretty obvious to me that you two belong together!
Here’s an odd one for ya … my hubby is almost 13 years older than I (hey, gals mature faster than guys
) and is almost a full year older than my step-mother (who is more than 8 years younger than my dad). I think it’s funny … they all think I’m weird for pointing it out.
And Marty … Happy Birthday! Have a most awesome and wonderful day! *smooches*
Too funny! I think Marty and I make a pretty good pair, too.
Marty’s mom is technically old enough to be my grandmother, and the first time she met my mom, she took me aside, appalled, and said “You never told me I was old enough to be your mother’s mother!”. Right– like I would have EVER told my mother-in-law that! “PS: MIL, you’re old enough to be my grandma. Just so you know!”
I like rules that strengthen the value of flexibility to avoid rigid adherence to them. There has to be a better way of describing that. Perhaps we’re talking about a spectrum of inclinations, practises, general policies, principles, and rules.
Birthdays are good things to celebrate, as a rule.
Happy Birthday Marty!
Thanks, Dean! We had an awesome day today checking out the beaches at Cowichan Bay. Marty’s so wise and mature now!
Dana, Thanks for sharing about your relationship. You were definitely right to modify your rule so that you and Marty could continue your relationship, so happy for you both! (and a happy birthday of course to Marty!)
Thanks, christyb! I’m pretty cowardly when it comes to breaking rules, but I think it’s safe to say that my act of disobedience was for the greater good in this instance.
Tom is 16 years older than me… which is only gross when you stop and think about it. Luckily, he forgets to pick up his socks and thinks poop jokes are hysterical, so nobody ever thinks about his age
Happy Happy Birthday to Marty MaChickChick!
Yes, it only becomes weird when people say things like “When he was in college, you were only ‘x’ years old”. They never seem to remember that we didn’t start dating when I was 10 and he was 20. We were both legal adults by the time we hooked up!
Well, Sara is only two years older than me, so that’s nothing. But thank God you mentioned the hummus, cause Sara and I are sometimes guilty of serving that to guests. Now we’ll know. If you and Marty ever make it to our part of the planet, wherever that happens to be, I will keep the hummus in the frig, where if belongs–for god sakes. Neanderthal, hummus-serving hosts!
Happy birthday, Marty!
Hugs,
Kathy
Too funny, Kathy– but of course you can serve *us* hummus, now that you know in advance that we love it!
I make a pretty mean hummus with loads of garlic in it, so when I serve it to friends, everyone in the vicinity has to eat it as a rule. We either ALL reek of garlic or nobody can try it at all.
Consider these the addenda to the No Serving Hummus To Guests rule: 1. It’s OK to serve hummus if you know beforehand that your guests like it, or if they request it specifically 2. When serving hummus to guests, everyone must partake in the eating of it. That way, everyone becomes immune to each other’s garlic breath.
Happy Birthday Marty! I hope you guys had a great day celebrating!
We had an awesome day– thanks! I’ll post pics of our shoreline stroll in an upcoming entry.
Brad’s 40th birthday is on Monday! I wonder if you have age rules for friends too.
Happy Birthday Marty!!
No age rules for friends– I have so few real-life friends to begin with, so setting age restrictions wouldn’t do me any favours!
Happy birthday in advance to Brad! Are you guys doing anything special?
Age is but a state of mind. and numbers are just numbers. Glad you both broke the rules. Hope you both enjoyed the day.
Thanks, Lesley! We definitely had a terrific day and it’s so true– age is just a number.
I love a good love story.
I know I’m late. Marty will just have to celebrate again. Happy Birthday, Marty!
I’m a firm believer that birthdays can never be celebrated for too long. Last week, we dragged Marty’s celebration out for a week, and mine was basically celebrated from January to June! Thanks for the birthday wishes– I’ll pass them on to Marty.
Happy belated birthday, Marty! (Glad you guys are believers in long celebrations.) I love reading about your love story.
Totally! We’re *still* celebrating his birthday. Just got back from a weekend of festivities, in fact!